Personal Insurance for Individuals and Families

Whether you are looking for private health insurance or additional protection for your personal property, we can help. We have been solving the insurance needs of individuals and families in central Indiana since 1873.

Work with MBAH or Heiny Insurance and we will save you time, effort and money. One independent agent will handle all the details of your auto and home insurance and so much more, which means you can rest easy knowing your risks are covered by a partner you can trust.

Does Discount Insurance Really Save Money?

Newcomers to our agency ask about insurance discounts and promises of cheaper coverage offered by others. As our loyal customers will tell you, there may be a lower insurance rate, but when you truly compare coverage and service, we have little competition in central Indiana.

Our offices in Lafayette and Monticello are staffed with dedicated professionals who can help you find exactly the coverage you need. If you own guns, expensive jewelry or an art collection, and provide a fair insurance quote.

Of course, insurance is about much more than the quote. Work with MBAH and you will enjoy friendly, prompt customer service from our team of experienced professionals. Should you ever need to file a claim, you will deal directly with our local customer service representatives rather than wait for return calls from an unknown claims department at a large insurance company.

We have been doing business in Indiana for more than 100 years, and in that time we have established long-term relationships with highly rated insurance companies that share our high standards. As your life changes, so do your insurance needs. We have insurance partners for every situation who will work as hard to earn your business as we do.

Personal Insurance Products

Rely on us over the course of your lifetime for a wide range of insurance solutions for your home and family:

Contact Us for Personal Insurance

We proudly serve personal and commercial insurance customers in Lafayette, Monticello, Logansport, Renssalaer, Indianapolis, Valparaiso and Merrillville. Contact us today, and we will make you feel at home.