Heiny Insurance Agents

When you walk in the Heiny Insurance office on Main Street in Monticello, you see our entire team hard at work serving our customers, many of whom have trusted their insurance needs to the independent agents at Heiny Insurance for many decades. We operate on many of the same principles William Heiny built the original Heiny Insurance Agency on back in 1873.

Our experienced staff will assist you in every way possible so that you can be confident your insurance needs are being met. You can trust us to answer your questions or provide claims assistance in a timely manner. Whether it is business insurance you are seeking or car, home and umbrella coverage for your family, contact the agents at Heiny Insurance.


John Willis, CIC — President — Email John

Mike Brummett — Vice President — Email Mike

Jay Spry — Treasurer — Email Jay

Phil Baer — Secretary — Email Phil



Phil Baer — Producer — Email Phil

Brad Chesterman, CSRM — Producer — Email Brad

Courtney Bradshaw, IACSR — ProducerEmail Courtney

Kevin Sparks — ProducerEmail Kevin

Angie Cunningham — Account Manager — Email Angie

Cathy Zook Producer & Account Manager Email Cathy

Jenni Duff, AIC, SCLA — Claims SpecialistEmail Jenni 



Courtney Bradshaw, IACSR — Producer — Email Courtney

Betty Denton, IACSR — Account Manager — Email Betty



Phil Baer — Producer — Email Phil

Kim Wiley — Account Manager — Email Kim

Sean Brummett — Producer — Email Sean


Life & Health

Kevin Sparks — ProducerEmail Kevin

Jay Spry — Producer — Email Jay



Cathy Zook Producer & Account Manager Email Cathy



Jenni Duff, AIC, SCLA — Claims SpecialistEmail Jenni 



Kim Wiley — Agency Manager Email Kim