Compare Indiana Insurance Companies

Over the years we have developed relationships with many national and regional insurance companies, such as Best Life, Nationwide, Anthem, Travelers, United, and West Bend Mutual to name a few. The manner in which we educate our customers and continually review their coverage to ensure they have the best policy for their needs is a source of great pride.

Claims Contact

One of the benefits for MBAH and Heiny Insurance customers is that our Lafayette staff provides claims assistance directly. You will receive local, friendly customer service from our team, whether your policy is from a national company like Progressive or an area firm like Cincinnati Insurance.

If you have a claim to report during normal business hours, please contact us at 765-423-5421. If you need to report a claim after hours, you may contact your insurance company claims support number listed below.

For more information or answers to specific questions regarding your insurance coverage, contact our experienced agents today.

 

  • Accident Fund
    Customer Service & Claims: 866-206-5851
    Website | Report a Claim

  • ACUITY
    Customer Service: 920-458-9131 (Corporate)
    Claims & Billing: 800-242-7666
    Website

  • Allied
    Claims & Billing:
    800-282-1446 (Personal)
    866-322-3214 (Commercial)
    Customer Service: 800-532-1436
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Anthem
    Website | Customer Service

  • Auto Owners
    Customer Service: 517-323-1200
    Claims: 888-252-4626
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Berkshire Hathaway
    Commercial Auto: 800-488-2930
    Commercial Property: 877-212-3816
    Workers Compensation: 888-495-8949
    Claims: 800-356-5750
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Chubb group
    Claims & Customer Service:
    800-699-9916 (Workers Compensation)
    800-252-4670 (All Others)
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Cincinnati
    Customer Service: 888-242-8811
    Claims: 877-242-2544
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Continental Western
    Customer Service: 800-235-2942
    Billing: 877-385-9114
    Claims: 866-232-6724
    Website | Report a Claim

  • FCCI Insurance Group
    Claims & Customer Service: 800-226-3224
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Great American
    Customer Service: 513-369-5000
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Guardian
    Customer Service: 212-598-8000
    Website | Manage Account

  • Hagerty Insurance
    Customer Service: 877-922-9701
    Claims: 888-220-9565
    Website

  • Harleysville
    Customer Service: 800-338-8301
    Claims: 800-892-8877
    Flood Claim: 800-421-3535
    Website

  • Heartland Crop Insurance
    Customer Service: 888-789-5566
    Website

  • Indiana Farmers
    Customer Service: 800-666-6460
    Billing: 888-809-3434
    Claims: 800-666-6460
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Jackson National Life
    Customer Service: 517-381-5500
    Website

  • Jewelers Mutual
    Personal Jewelry: 888-884-2424
    Business Jewelry: 800-558-6411
    Website

  • Liberty Mutual Insurance
    Customer Service: 800-837-5254
    Billing: 877-566-6011
    Claims: 800-362-0000
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Mutual of Omaha
    Website | Customer Service

  • Nationwide Agribusiness
    Customer Service: 877-669-6877
    Claims: 800-228-6700
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Principal Financial Group
    Customer Service: 800-986-3343

  • Progressive
    Claims & Customer Service: 800-776-4737
    Billing: 800-PROGRESSIVE
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Safeco
    Claims & Customer Service:
    800-332-3226
    Billing: 888-723-3260
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Selective Insurance
    Customer Service: 800-735-3284
    Billing: 888-974-7400
    Claims: 866-455-9969
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Society Insurance
    Claims:
    888-576-2438 (Business hours)
    800-945-7120 (After hours)
    Customer Service: 888-576-2438
    Website | Report a Claim

  • State Auto
    Claims: 800-766-1853
    Website | Report a Claim

  • Travelers
    Customer Service: 866-336-2077
    Billing: 800-842-5075
    Claims: 800-252-4633
    Website | Report a Claim

  • United Fire Group
    Customer Service: 800-553-7937
    Claims: 800-343-9131
    Website | Report a Claim

  • United Healthcare
    Website | Customer Service

  • USLI
    Customer Service: 800-523-5545
    Billing: 866-632-2003
    Website | Report a claim

  • West Bend Mutual
    Customer Service: 800-236-5010
    Billing: 800-573-1323
    Claims: 877-922-5246
    Website | Report a Claim