Heiny Insurance Protecting White County Farms and Families Since 1873

Visit the Heiny Insurance Agency on North Main Street in Monticello, and you will see the original desk and office mementos used by William Heiny when he opened his insurance agency in 1873. Bill’s reputation grew rapidly as the one to see for farm insurance and fair claim settlements.

In those days, Bill traveled by horse and buggy throughout White County, Jasper County and the surrounding area. He carried insurance policies in his pocket and provided farmers and families from Rensselaer to Logansport with instant protection, an innovation at that time.

Heiny Insurance was built on a philosophy that has not changed significantly in nearly 140 years. We treat our clients like family. Our objective is to provide high-quality insurance products and personal service. We know that insurance is a complex topic, so we take time to explain the purpose of the insurance solutions we recommend and ensure that your insurance is tailored to fit your unique needs.

Heiny Insurance is an award-winning agency that has been recognized by national and regional insurance organizations for its outstanding management and progressive customer service. We strive to find the best value for your premium dollar by seeking quotes from multiple insurance providers.

The independent agents at Heiny Insurance offer:

  • Small business insurance
  • Agribusiness and farm insurance
  • Group plans and employee benefits
  • Home and auto insurance
  • Truckers insurance
  • Large Commercial

Heiny Joins MBAH in 2007

In 2007, Heiny Insurance joined forces with MBAH in Lafayette, IN, to take advantage of the additional resources available through a larger agency. Heiny Insurance customers now have access to competitive quotes from even more insurance companies and an in-house Claims and Loss Management (CALM) department.

Contact the experienced staff at Heiny Insurance or stop in the office to learn more about how we may assist you with a wide range of solutions, including farm and crop insurance, car insurance and more. We proudly serve businesses and families in Monticello, Rensselaer, Logansport, Valparaiso and surrounding communities.